There is one place named The Old Settler in Canada.
All places in the world called "The Old Settler".
Wellington (4)
Windsor (4)
Victoria (3)
Kingston (3)
Havelock (3)
Sidney (3)
Centreville (3)
Princeton (3)
Borden (3)
Westport (3)
Milton (3)
Richmond (3)
Benton (3)
Saint Andrews (3)
Selkirk (3)
Tracadie (3)
Radisson (2)
Saint Louis (2)
Stanley (2)
Waterloo (2)
Alma (2)
Boundary (2)
Chipman (2)
Durham (2)
Grand Falls (2)
Laflèche (2)
Morden (2)
Rosedale (2)
Seaforth (2)
Tiverton (2)