There is one place named Plum Island in Canada.
All places in the world called "Plum Island".
Wellington (4)
Windsor (4)
Centreville (3)
Sidney (3)
Borden (3)
Princeton (3)
Westport (3)
Milton (3)
Richmond (3)
Benton (3)
Saint Andrews (3)
Selkirk (3)
Tracadie (3)
Kingston (3)
Victoria (3)
Havelock (3)
Benton Station (2)
Delisle (2)
Frobisher (2)
Keswick (2)
Marysville (2)
Port Burwell (2)
Saint George (2)
Valleyfield (2)
Badger (2)
Burwash (2)
Clyde River (2)
Elgin (2)
Griffin (2)
Lethbridge (2)