There are 3 places named Bay Island in Canada.
All places in the world called "Bay Island".
Wellington (4)
Windsor (4)
Borden (3)
Princeton (3)
Westport (3)
Milton (3)
Richmond (3)
Benton (3)
Saint Andrews (3)
Selkirk (3)
Tracadie (3)
Kingston (3)
Victoria (3)
Havelock (3)
Centreville (3)
Sidney (3)
Badger (2)
Burwash (2)
Clyde River (2)
Elgin (2)
Griffin (2)
Lethbridge (2)
Murray Harbour (2)
Redwater (2)
Saint-Paul (2)
Stratford (2)
Belmont (2)
Cartwright (2)
Deer (2)
Fort Hope (2)